Alibaba Faces US Shareholder Suit Over Ties to Megaspeed

The proposed class action names chief executive Eddie Wu and covers Alibaba ADS holders from May 2024, citing a 14% share fall over four days in November.

WHY IT MATTERS

The Nvidia chip scandal now carries legal cost for Alibaba, which already faces an August securities suit over its Pentagon listing and its AI-development disclosures.

An Alibaba Group shareholder has sued the company and its chief executive, Eddie Wu, in a proposed class action filed in Manhattan federal court on Thursday, November 19, Reuters reported. The plaintiff, Withida Bihan, alleges that Alibaba inflated its share price by "knowingly and materially understating" in its 2024, 2025 and 2026 annual reports the risk that actual or suspected export-control violations could damage its business. The suit seeks unspecified damages for holders of Alibaba’s American depositary shares (ADS) between May 23, 2024, and November 11, 2026.

The case rests on Alibaba’s relationship with Megaspeed, the Singapore company suspected of helping Beijing obtain advanced Nvidia AI chips. Megaspeed executive Alice Huang is the suspected Chinese spy whose relationship with Jensen Huang preceded his resignation as Nvidia’s chief executive last week; the two are not related. The shareholders point to media reports that Alibaba had become Megaspeed’s "dominant" customer. Alibaba did not immediately respond to requests for comment, Reuters said, and Hong Kong outlet Dimsum Daily reported no formal response by Friday morning.

Until now the Megaspeed affair had reached Alibaba through its share price and through the prospect of tighter US chip rules. The suit turns it into a legal claim against Alibaba and its top executive. The allegations have not been tested in court.

The complaint ties four days of losses to Megaspeed reports

According to the shareholders, Alibaba’s stock fell 14% over four trading days after reports on its ties to Alice Huang and Megaspeed. A notice from Robbins LLP, a law firm seeking investors for the case, lists the drops the complaint cites. Alibaba’s ADS fell US$4.07, or 3.71%, to US$105.38 on November 9 after a Financial Times article on Alice Huang’s pitches of AI chip deals to investors, then lost 2.52% to US$102.72 on November 10. On November 11 they slipped 1.16% to US$101.52 after a New York Times profile of Alice Huang.

Alibaba’s American depositary shares fell US$7.16, or 7.05%, to US$94.36 on November 12, the largest of the four drops the complaint cites. The shareholders attribute part of that fall to a Reuters article the same day saying the scandal could push Washington to tighten limits on Chinese AI companies’ remote use of advanced processors. EastFrontier reported on November 13 that Alibaba’s Hong Kong shares closed 6.8% lower that day.

The class period ends on November 11, the day of the New York Times profile, and starts on May 23, 2024, so it spans the three annual reports the complaint challenges.

The suit treats chip-supply exposure as a disclosure failure

The complaint frames the issue as a matter of securities law. As summarized by Robbins LLP, it alleges that Alibaba failed to disclose a business relationship with Alice Huang and, through her, with Megaspeed, which is suspected of smuggling hardware into China. Those ties, the plaintiffs argue, raised the chance of reputational damage and the risk that Alibaba would lose the ability to buy products subject to US export controls, making its public statements about its business materially false or misleading.

The case adds to Alibaba’s legal disputes in the United States. In August, investor Carl Wistisen filed a proposed class action in the Southern District of New York alleging that Alibaba understated the risk of being designated a Chinese military company and misrepresented risks tied to its AI-development methods, Bloomberg Law reported. The Defense Department added Alibaba to that list on June 8. Alibaba sued the US government over the listing in June, and last month a California federal judge barred the government from denying Pentagon contracts to companies whose lobbyists also work for listed Chinese military companies, Reuters reported. Nvidia faces its own shareholder suits over the scandal.

Washington’s next move on Megaspeed will shape the case

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC on November 13 that Treasury, Defense, State and the US Trade Representative had favored adding Megaspeed to the Entity List, the US trade blacklist, for months, as EastFrontier reported on November 16. He blamed the Commerce Department, which controls the list, for the delay.

Wu addressed the US pressure on Thursday without referring to the suit. Reporting quarterly results, he said Alibaba remains on track for US$100 billion in external cloud revenue and a 20% EBITDA margin by 2030, despite US curbs on computing power that could affect its products next year, Reuters reported. Dimsum Daily said Alibaba’s Hong Kong shares rose 2% in early trading on Friday.

A Federal Register listing of Megaspeed would put an official US finding about the company on the record that the plaintiffs could cite.