China Opposes Abuse of Export Controls as Bessent Blames Commerce Over Megaspeed

Beijing warned Washington off new chip curbs days before APEC in Shenzhen, as Treasury said four US agencies had wanted Megaspeed blacklisted for months.

WHY IT MATTERS

Chip curbs now sit on the agenda of this week's Shenzhen APEC meeting, while a fight inside the Trump administration decides whether Megaspeed and other suspected diversion channels get blacklisted.

China’s foreign ministry used its regular briefing on Friday, November 13, to push back against the next round of US chip restrictions now taking shape in Washington. Asked by Bloomberg about new chip bills in Congress and a reported Commerce Department plan to stop Chinese firms renting American computing power overseas, spokesperson Mao Ning said China "opposes abuse of export control measures, which disrupt the stability of global industrial and supply chains and serve no one’s interests," according to the ministry’s English transcript. She added that the two countries "need to work together to deliver on the important common understandings between the two presidents."

The same day in Washington, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC that the Commerce Department, run by Howard Lutnick, was the reason Singapore-based Megaspeed has not been added to the Entity List, the US trade blacklist. Treasury, Defense, State and the US Trade Representative "were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months," Bessent told CNBC. Megaspeed is the data center company whose former executive Alice Huang is reported to have had an affair with Jensen Huang, who resigned as Nvidia’s chief executive on Thursday after admitting to an affair, as EastFrontier reported. US officials suspect her of spying for China.

The new element is that the scandal has turned into a policy fight on both sides. Beijing is framing any tightening as a breach of the leaders’ understandings ahead of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ meeting, while Washington is arguing over who let chips through.

Beijing ties chip curbs to the leaders’ understandings before Shenzhen

Mao’s language on November 13 was measured. The ministry’s Chinese-language record has her saying China "一贯反对" (has consistently opposed) the abuse of export controls, and calling on both sides to maintain the "稳定发展态势" (momentum of stable development) in economic and trade ties. On Bloomberg’s report that banned Nvidia chips had reached a Shanghai data center linked to Alice Huang, she said she was "not familiar with the situation." Asked about CNN reporting that US intelligence was still assessing Alice Huang’s ties to the Chinese government, she said only that China had made its position on the "Chinese spy" allegation clear.

That position was set out a day earlier. At the November 12 briefing, answering a BBC question on whether the scandal would affect a likely presidential summit, Mao said: "The U.S. should stop fabricating the ‘Chinese spy’ narratives as a pretext for imposing technology restrictions." The Chinese version uses the stronger 科技封锁, a technology blockade; CBS News, drawing on AFP, rendered it as a "technological blockade." EastFrontier covered Beijing’s first rejection of the spy claim on November 10.

The timing explains the restraint. Xinhua reported on November 13 that President Xi Jinping will chair the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen on November 18 and 19, and hold bilateral meetings on the sidelines. On Friday, Mao also said China was in contact with "relevant parties" about a meeting of the Chinese, US and Russian heads of state. Neither government had confirmed a Xi-Trump meeting in Shenzhen by Sunday.

Treasury says Commerce held the pen on Megaspeed

Bessent’s comments put the internal dispute on the record. "Commerce has the pen," he said, according to a Reuters report carried by The Standard, adding that reporters would "have to ask them about their internal processes." He said the administration has "all the authorities that we need," which "just need to be implemented," and that President Trump had made clear China should not get Nvidia chips above the H100. "I think that there is a lot of leakage in the system," he told CNBC, and he questioned whether Nvidia had known its customer.

Commerce disputes parts of the account. A spokeswoman, Kristen Eichamer, told CNBC that Bessent and Lutnick had "no such conversation" in the White House Situation Room, as Axios had reported, and said Lutnick had "proactively agreed to appear voluntarily" before the Senate Banking Committee. A US official told CBS News that the testimony is set for December 10.

Pressure in Congress is building. CBS News reported that House Speaker Mike Johnson said a growing consensus supports tighter chip export controls on China. Republican Senator John Curtis said Lutnick’s reported stalling "raises the question of whether the Commerce Department is acting in the best interests of the American people," the Reuters report said, and Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal said "Lutnick must go."

A December run of hearings tests whether the blacklist moves

The House committees on China, intelligence and foreign affairs have asked Huang for a closed-door briefing on December 1 and Nvidia general counsel Tim Teter for an interview on December 2, CNBC reported. House Foreign Affairs Chairman Brian Mast asked Jeff Kessler, the Commerce under secretary for industry and security, to appear on December 3.

Beijing is also looking for other suppliers. A Global Times commentary on November 13, as reported by Seoul Economic Daily, urged South Korean chipmakers to sell their most advanced memory in China and Seoul to press Washington to allow it. The clearest signal to watch is a Federal Register notice adding Megaspeed to the Entity List, and whether it appears before or after Xi and Trump meet.